Do We Have A Political Obligation?

Inkwell Institute

Professor’s Classroom

Subject:  Political Theory

Paper #8A

(this is a re-post from several months ago)

This begins my week or so of post that relate to the approaching mid-terms…..

As I write my posts, from time to time, one idea morphs into more ideas and so on….as I was writing my recent series on political theory I thought of another issue that compels me to write about….that is the political obligation of the people… the beginning of the debate along these lines, back in the 16th century, your political obligation meant that you will obey the rules and laws of the state, the political authority….. (a post in the making)…….but I think it has evolved since the original debate….now it is the so-called obligation that Americans have to vote…..

I knew this one would be a bitch and so far I am spot on……there are complicated parts of this issue that I will try to simplify….to me it is a fascinating debate but then I enjoy politics……everyone is not that lucky or maybe that should be that…… mentally ill…..

Let us go back to the classical definition, well as far back as Plato, at least, one of the earliest of the political philosophers, in his Crito, he addressed the subject of obligation…..basically, it is what the person must do for the protection of a political authority, the State…….men would obey laws and rules for which the State protects the man.  Most political philosophers were concerned with man’s relationship to the authority….but how do we come by this obligation?  First, we have it as part of our self-interest and then a forced obligation, which is basically that it is the law of the land and you WILL obey or face the consequences… I have said…political obligation is a complex idea that will keep us political philosophers busy for a millennium trying to find the answer…..hopefully, there is a little clarity here…..

Now what about a more modern definition–while political obligation will keep the philosophers busy, what about the common man…..the man on the street?  To Billy Bubba the political obligation is the one to vote….a person that does not vote is un-American….why?……it is the duty (obligation) of every Americans to cast his/her vote……simple huh?

Hate to say so, but the idea that it is an obligation to cast a vote is dumb….for lack of a more appropriate word……the truth of the matter is that voting is NOT a political obligation more like an exercise in futility…..okay, think it is an obligation, then let us look at the exercise of voting…..

First if voting is truly a political obligation then education on the issues is an obligation….in reality the average American voter is ignorant of the issues, with the exception of the one that means something to them, i.e.  guns, abortion, etc……beyond the single issue there is ignorance with the voter, for the most part….

In a representative democracy voting serves one purpose…….to legitimize…..the act of voting in this atmosphere is not the “magic wand” that the elites claim it is….they control who and what is the rule of law…in reality the people have little say….an occassional poll or questionnaire from the Rep is only to give the appearance that they care of the opinion of those ruled…the agenda was set when they decided what party and what issues were to be their main focus….

So do we have a political obligation?  In the classical sense, yes we do….we must and I emphasize the word MUST, give up some personal freedoms to secure protection by the State…..and in the more “modern” sense then the answer is NO!  We have no obligation to vote, especially under representative system of governance… is apparent that the American people do NOT feel they have a political obligation for on an average of 50% of us actually car enough to vote on any given issue…if Americans had more of an insight to political thought then they would also agree…..but the propaganda machine of both parties work overtime, especially close to an election, to try and force people to turn out and vote for them…..Do We Have A Political Obligation?

15 thoughts on “Do We Have A Political Obligation?

  1. Absolutely not! Since, as you say, the ONLY object of voting is to provide apparent superficial legitimacy for those who will mostly NOT do what any individual wants, how can there be an obligation?

    If the democratic system worked in any way, shape, or form like the political elite claim, then that would be a very different matter, but as things are – no f*cking way, buster, it’s all just another con!

    1. We talked about this previously….and we are pretty much in agreement……but there are those that look down on someone who does not vote…..some are lazy and stupid and ……but some have looked at all candidates and see that there is nothing worth the effort because nothing will change….so why vote? A vote being some sort of BS obligation……

      1. To me, it’s more serious than that – more definite. In the UK, things have taken (I think – hope) a turn that is somewhat better).

        However, from what I read and the little I understand of US politics, I would object strongly to being encouraged or forced to vote for any of them simply because I wouldn’t want any of them. Even MORE strongly, though, I would object to being made to do or say ANYTHING that implied that I accepted ANYTHING about the whole system of delivering what THEY glibly call democracy – and I DON’T!

      2. Usually during the last week of the campaigns…radio talk shows, whether left or right, have lots of crap about what a duty voting is and to not vote is somehow un-American…..once again (surprise!) I agree……if neither of the bozos has a plan that I can support…no one gets support….now if they give me a choice like “none of the above” or an “against” box then I will be glad to cast a vote each and every time….but those are far between here….sadly…..

      3. I have been trying to find the site that is pushing the “against” initiative for all states……maybe I was delusional but I thought I saw a website in my readings…oh well…..

        Tomorrow will be my pragmatic post (my apologies)

    1. I have seen this sight before I believe, at least it looks familiar….but then I am old and my brain worms take control…lol

      I think Dylan Ratigan was pushing the ‘against’ vote…I will have to contact him and see if there is more info…

  2. Certainly agree with just what you said. Your explanation was certainly the simplest to comprehend. I tell you, I usually get annoyed any time folks discuss issues that these people obviously don’t know about. You were able to hit the nail on the head and spelled out the whole thing with out complication. Perhaps, folks could take a signal. Will likely be back to obtain more. Appreciate it

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.