Apologies for the potential double-tap [no pun intended]; I’m not sure if this posted at your linked site.
Of course, I’ll disagree….primarily since the entirety of the debate on the Citizens Right to bear arms cannot….and is not…summed up in an excerpt from Federalist 29. One must clearly take into account the writings [and philosophical genealogy] of the body of Founders, no? Such as Trenche Coxe, George Mason, Thomas Jefferson in his Commonplace Book, or the 1780 Massachusetts declaration of rights
Further, it stands to reason that if the excerpt was the definitive sole source on this topic, that what you refer to as “assault weapons” would absolutely be Constitutionally protected, as that is what the Militia is expected to be armed with.
I’d be interested in your thoughts on the Unorganized Militia, 10 U.S. Code § 246.
If I remembering right…..There is NO need….we have cops/NG there is not need for everyone to carry a gun….maybe if we were still at odds with the Brits or NDNs…but those days are gone. chuq
Really? There are still not criminal assaults occurring daily, before law enforcement id able to respond, if indeed they even do?
Loading...
True….but that was not the question…..we have militia so we do not a bunch of ppl running around pretending to be helping. chuq
Loading...
Indeed, to include the Unorganized Militia; I mentioned what I had, because you interjected law enforcement. I respectfully stand by my earlier response on Founders statements.
Loading...
I apologize for the comment but I was on my phone at the doctor’s and had to work quick….as I stand by mine….hope all is well where you are chuq
Apologies for the potential double-tap [no pun intended]; I’m not sure if this posted at your linked site.
Of course, I’ll disagree….primarily since the entirety of the debate on the Citizens Right to bear arms cannot….and is not…summed up in an excerpt from Federalist 29. One must clearly take into account the writings [and philosophical genealogy] of the body of Founders, no? Such as Trenche Coxe, George Mason, Thomas Jefferson in his Commonplace Book, or the 1780 Massachusetts declaration of rights
Further, it stands to reason that if the excerpt was the definitive sole source on this topic, that what you refer to as “assault weapons” would absolutely be Constitutionally protected, as that is what the Militia is expected to be armed with.
I’d be interested in your thoughts on the Unorganized Militia, 10 U.S. Code § 246.
If I remembering right…..There is NO need….we have cops/NG there is not need for everyone to carry a gun….maybe if we were still at odds with the Brits or NDNs…but those days are gone. chuq
Really? There are still not criminal assaults occurring daily, before law enforcement id able to respond, if indeed they even do?
True….but that was not the question…..we have militia so we do not a bunch of ppl running around pretending to be helping. chuq
Indeed, to include the Unorganized Militia; I mentioned what I had, because you interjected law enforcement. I respectfully stand by my earlier response on Founders statements.
I apologize for the comment but I was on my phone at the doctor’s and had to work quick….as I stand by mine….hope all is well where you are chuq