Is The Surge Succeeding?

I spend a lot of time on discussion forums for politics and of course I run across a few good posters, but for the most part, I am at odds with most of them. recently, I was discussing the Sirge with a few on a forum and in pops some, I will try to be polite, moron who does not want to exchange views but rather attack, name call and quote only stuff that supports his/her view.

This person says the Surge is working–and as proof they cite the fact that there are lulls or quiet tinmes in Baghdad. That means the surge is working. Then when violence erupts that means that the bad guys had to adjust before they could continue–and that means the surge is working.

After scratching my head for awhile, at the sheer lunacy of any of those observations; I just had to post.

We are fighting insurgents–that is what insurgents do–they fight–they back off–they regroup–they adjust. That is why they are so successful; the ability to readust to the tactics being employed against them..They are insurgents, not an army!

The best I can say is, crack must be getting cheaper, for that would be the only way to see the Surge as a success.