As a young man just returned from service in Vietnam I found myself protesting for an end to that war and all wars.
For me war is an obscene show of force….”mine is bigger than yours” sort of thing. There is nothing romantic or heroic about the destruction of life and limb.
After several trips to the local jail for defying a police order and the life caught up with me and I became a father and had tom get a “real job” and slowly my activism got less important but the feelings about war stayed with me and I wrote about them whenever I got the chance.
Somewhere in the absence from the movement and it died….and now all our wars, endless, senseless wars, go on and on unchallenged…..a sad thing indeed for the US had a proud history of pacifism and protests…..
Resistance to war is as old as war itself. The first recorded instance was a Christian, Maximilian, who was executed in the 3rd century AD for refusing to join the Roman army. There have been many other individuals who have refused to serve in war throughout history. But for the beginnings of a coherent peace movement, rather than individual resistance, we have to look to the 19th century.
In America, the first pamphlets calling for an organised anti-war movement were distributed in 1814, and the first meeting of the New York Peace Society followed a year afterwards. Soon there were chapters all over America, and similar societies in Europe too. The American Peace Society was officially founded in 1828.
During World War I, a large number of men resisted conscription on the grounds of conscientious objection to war. Some were made to pay fines, and many others were sent to prison. The No-Conscription Fellowship was formed in 1914, and grew into a substantial movement once conscription was introduced in 1916. Some of these objectors went on to found War Resisters’ International in the aftermath of the war. The War Resisters’ League, its American branch, was set up a couple of years later in 1923, and both groups are still actively campaigning today.
It wasn’t until the Vietnam War, however, that the anti-war movement began to really take hold in the public imagination. Opposition to the war became less individual and, inspired by the Civil Rights movement, took the form of widespread, large-scale demonstrations attended by people from all walks of life. Starting with small demonstrations on university campuses around the United States in 1964 the movement grew quickly, with several marches of hundreds of thousands of people throughout the USA and in Europe over the following years. In 1969, the November 15th Moratorium March in Washington, D.C. was attended by over half a million people.
http://www.ushistory.org/us/55d.asp
So I asked….what happened to the antiwar movement?
Years ago, most Americans decided that the war in Iraq was not worth fighting. That judgment helped elect Barack Obama president in 2008. Last year, for the first time, a majority of those polled said it had been a mistake to send forces into Afghanistan as well. Support for both wars has been steadily declining since Obama first took office.
So why, given the unpopularity of American involvement, is there not and has there never been a sizable movement to demand that the U.S. military withdraw from either nation? This absence is an extraordinary phenomenon: two of the longest wars in American history entirely lack the kind of organized, sustained opposition that emerged during nearly every other major armed conflict the United States has fought over the past two centuries.
Why Is There No Antiwar Movement?
There are other theories and articles to why there is no substantial antiwar movement anymore in this country…
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/where-has-the-antiwar-mov_b_815073
https://nationalinterest.org/feature/peace-pass%C3%A9-why-pacifist-movement-died-90321
We need a strong antiwar movement to keep the power brokers honest (as honest as they can ever be)…..we have had enough wars and far way too long…..
Just a musical interlude after a somber post…..
I Read, I Wrote, You Know
“Lego Ergo Scribo”
“So why, given the unpopularity of American involvement, is there not and has there never been a sizable movement to demand that the U.S. military withdraw from either nation?”
Because that would interfere with watching the football game and getting high and it’s someone else’s father or brother that got killed. I recall during Vietnam the Miami Herald published a daily list of KIA’s from South Florida.
Carl has got it about right. If it’s not your family getting killed, it’s time to check in on Facebook and look at photos of what your friends are having for dinner.
Best wishes, Pete.
and if it is your family getting killed, then it is time to mourn for awhile and await that big compensation check. Every living human being has now been assigned a “Price Per Pound” by somebody who stands to profit from the demise of the specie.
John that is capitalism’s answer…..dollars for death….chuq
yes it is. No doubt about it.
So sad I say….chuq
This ties in with your post about Wilson. We were sold on the idea of installing democratic governments all over the world. We used whatever. means were available, including military force. W Bush, Obama snd Trump all campaigned and won vowing to stop the wars. Neither had been successful against the media, MIC and public opinion that still wants us to dominate and police the world
Thanx OG for seeing the tie in….I appreciate it….chuq
Not is there little or no anti-war movement anymore, but there are Right Wing nutjobs fondling their guns and wanting a civil war… even Trump is promoting to save his fat ass.
Bloodthristy indeed…chuq
The anti-war movement was paid off and bought and paid for by the passing of time and their absorption into the allures and temptations of the Capitalist society that makes enormous profits from war and wartime enterprises … which is only human nature … and as long as the almighty dollar dominates the political dialogue, there will never be peace because peace is not profitable and in America, the dollar always outshines and outweighs morality. The archaic and ageing remnants of the anti-war movement are simply politically impotent and derelativized. (Made irrelevant by the passing of time and the changing of circumstances, attitudes and paradigms.)
And that is capitalism’s greatest failure….the worship of cash….chuq