Remember about 8 or 9 years ago the raging debate on water boarding and torture in general? It raged on and on….many opinions and many theories…..some even went so far as to protest the technique……I bring this up because a couple of weeks ago I gave a lecture at the local Jr. College on international relations……we talked about Middle East Peace…..and Ukraine and one student brought up this torture document that all are raving about….. I let the class go back and forth stopping and asking a question here and there and t\let them continue to debate….after about a half hour I brought it to a halt……
I told them that it was good to see the lively exchanges…which it was….I finally asked the entire class…….have any of you ever been tortured? Of course, none had but a few tried to use some bullying as a torture….did not fly……they all stared at me for a moment before I said……
“Try It Then We Will Talk”!
I then went on to tell them that without first hand knowledge of what is involved and the physical aspects of the technique they have an opinion but it is a worthless opinion.
I bring this up because we are having the debate all over again……and as usual it is not about the technique…it is about the politics of the report……