My regulars know that I am not a fan of the Democratic Party or Dems in general. In my opinion they are nothing more than the other side of the conservative coin.
The only Dems I have any respect for are those that are of a different party but caucus with the Dems….
But what went wrong?
The Democratic Party once imagined itself as the engine of meaningful American transformation. First FDR revamped the relationship between the government and the people, then, in 1944, in his “Second Bill of Rights,” he proposed economic guarantees that would have rewritten the country’s legal and economic foundations. This would have entailed a huge structural change as the role of government would have moved further from a mere defender of freedoms to a guarantor of economic well-being.
Every American was to have the right to a job, the right to housing, the right to medical care, the right to education and the right to protection from economic fear. FDR stated that people in economic need could not fully participate in a democracy and we needed economic reform to ensure everyone had the economic security to participate in democratic governance and move the country in a humane direction.
But the Second Bill of Rights died with Roosevelt, so Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society then attempted to attack poverty, racial segregation/injustice and inequality at their structural roots, closely following many of Roosevelt’s proposals. The Great Society was however, hampered by congressional resistance, the budgetary and political drain of Vietnam and white backlash to civil rights.
There were victories, however: the creation of Medicare and Medicaid, the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, which sent federal funding into public schools serving low‑income children; Head Start; the Voting Rights Act and Civil Rights Act enforcement mechanisms, which dismantled Jim Crow; the Higher Education Act, which opened college access to working‑class students through grants and loans; the creation of public broadcasting; the National Endowments for the Arts and Humanities and major environmental laws like the Clean Air and Water Quality Acts.
Yet, despite these victories, we did not see real structural change because the Great Society was only allowed to alter the symptoms of American inequality without changing the underlying power arrangements that produced those symptoms. It expanded services but did not redistribute power and it created programs for the poor but left the economic order that manufactured poverty fully intact. The result was apparent progress without real transformation and reforms that improved lives while leaving the basic mechanisms of injustice standing.
At one time the Dems were considered the “Left”….and in some less informed circles they still refer to them as the Left…but they are far from any representation of a true Left ideology.
Why?
Many years ago they abandoned the class struggle…..the working class.
That tradition began with a sharp diagnosis. Karl Marx argued that capitalism rests on a class relationship in which those who own the means of production extract surplus value from those who own only their labor power. One did not have to accept the inevitability of revolution to accept the centrality of class, and Bernstein did not. He kept the analysis and changed the method, betting that universal suffrage could be turned into economic democracy.
That bet defined what the old left stood for. It was not merely taxing the rich and redistributing the proceeds, the liberal project of John Stuart Mill and later John Maynard Keynes, but democratizing economic decision making itself. The New Deal and the Great Society were humane achievements, yet they were state capitalism for the benefit of the many and left the boardroom intact. The democratic socialist asked a harder question: who decides what gets built, where capital flows, and whose work disappears?
Put most simply, the socialist project was about extending democracy into the economy. We accept that the people should govern the state, that no king or boss may rule a polity by private right. The socialist asked why the same principle stops at the factory gate, why the firm that shapes a person’s waking life should remain a little monarchy exempt from the democratic rule we demand everywhere else.
https://znetwork.org/znetarticle/what-is-wrong-with-the-american-left-the-abandonment-of-class/
We need a true Left in this country…..what we have now is just two corrupt parties that are for sale….the people meant absolutely nothing the the Congress as a whole.
We need a Left Party!
I Read, I Write, You Know
“lego ergo scribo”
That is a spot-on and succinct summarization. I would also argue that the Democratic Party since the Clinton presidency has been decreasingly interested in incrementalism. Now, they are in a defensive self-preservation mode. The opposite-sides-of-the-same-coin analogy is apropos. It is my opinion that the Democratic Party leadership would choose what we have now – i.e. a tyrannical quasi-fascist regime like Trump’s – over a socialist administration or even what we had under FDR or LBJ.
I agree that the Dems fell apart ever since Clinton but it started its slow demise with Reagan. chuq
Other than a small spate of non-relevant, out-dated, self-appointed armchair politicians and some archaic activists whose day has come and gone, the Democrats are the only hope for America unless one likes the vibe presented by some kind of radical right-ism visage locked in a mental vacuum.
Some ‘archaic activist’….I have been called a lot of things but that one stings. The Dems are no hope unless you like conserv policies. We need flamboyant leadership now more than ever. chuq
“Actually, the New Deal’s central dedication was to business recovery rather than social reform.” —Michael Parenti, Democracy for the Few
I used to think that the Democratic Party was the working class party, but after the 2000 presidential election realized that wasn’t true. I see no difference between the Democratic and Republican parties, anymore. Thanks for the articles!
From the first linked article in this post, FDR’s “Second Bill of Rights” proposal in 1944 was quoted which would have restructured the American economy around labor had he not died in the Spring of 1945.
Tina it really gave up on the working class in 1980 and it just keeps getting worse every year. chuq
IMO, the Democratic Party surely has its faults (and maybe more so in the last few years), but I would hope they have not fallen enough that they would elect someone like Trump to lead this country.
I believe they have, Nan, but they would never admit it publicly.
Nan they will say they are helping us but looking at the policies they actually vote on….they are helping nobody but themselves and their donors. chuq
If you had a genuine Left-Wing party representing workers, do you think enough people would vote for it for it to get anywhere? To be honest, I don’t think so. The USA has been seeing ‘reds under the ebd’ my whole lifetime, and one of the biggest insults Joe Public can appear to throw at someone is to call them a ‘Commie’.
Best wishes, Pete.
*’under the bed’. Typo.
Pete, as long as the U.S. keeps its arbitrary and exclusive two-party system favoring Republicans and Democrats, then a “genuine” leftwing (i.e. socialist, not communist which is undemocratic and totalitarian) party representing workers would have no chance to become anything more than a minor player.
However, that could change. If the Democratic Party collapsed from loss of support (which has happened before such as the demise of the Whigs), then the resulting power vacuum would naturally be filled by worker-oriented interests. The American political center has been steadily eroding this century. It has taken the lion-share of the blame for this country’s failures. People are frustrated and angry and are looking for alternatives. It’s what enabled Trump’s rise to power. Anything is possible going forward.
Pete the young are showing more interests in unions and the working class….so for now they could make a difference. chuq
Donate to Our “Empty the Shelters” Fund https://pawfund.pages.dev