Why Is It Speculation’s Fault?

The first of these relates to the short-sightedness of speculators. During any asset price boom, the belief that it would go on for ever gradually gathers momentum; as a result the awareness of risk comes down, and more and more risky positions begin to be taken. Hence instead of such an asset-price boom getting truncated early, in which case the potentially-destabilizing impact of such truncation on the financial sphere would also be limited, it persists, making the financial system more and more fragile, until the end of the boom catches the entire financial system in an acute crisis.

The sub-prime crisis illustrates this point. As the real estate boom in the United States got underway, the euphoria about it began to increase. Financial firms became more and more reckless about supporting it. Credit was available to all and sundry, at one point up to the full value of the property being acquired, which itself was never carefully assessed.. To say this is not to argue that credit-giving institutions should be conservative in accommodating borrowers, but merely to underscore the fact that they are swayed by speculative considerations which make them reckless. They give credit in anticipation of rising house prices, since they expect this rise to continue. And when, for one reason or another, the rise in house prices reaches a plateau, the borrowers are caught short. To pay back their loans many of them are then forced to sell their property which brings down property prices. Finally, the time comes when the value of the assets against which the loans are given is way below the magnitude of the loans themselves. This is when the financial papers representing, directly or indirectly, claims upon real estate, are worth only a fraction of their face value, and the financial world gets into a crisis.

The second factor relates to the emergence of a vast “derivatives” market. A loan, say, for the acquisition of a piece of housing property, is typically thought of as a bilateral arrangement, between the lender and the borrower. In a modern financial sector however the risks associated with any loan are no longer borne exclusively by the lender but themselves become a marketable commodity. These risks are passed on to others through the “derivatives” market, who in turn pass them on to still others and so on. All this however does not mean that the risks themselves disappear or diminish; what it means is that there is a systematic undervaluation of risk since nobody quite knows what the risk associated with his/her portfolio of assets actually is. This piece of “financial innovation” therefore has the same effect as the first factor mentioned above, namely it leads to an underestimation of risk during any boom in asset prices, which makes such booms more prolonged and more pronounced, and the subsequent collapse in the asset prices more precipitous, and hence more calamitous for the world of finance.
The third factor has to do with government intervention. Whenever such a financial crisis, involving giants in the American financial market, looms large on the horizon, the government steps in to bail out these giants. Such government action may well be dictated by the desire to avoid a recession, but the awareness that the government will provide a bail-out also works in the direction of making financiers reckless, making them underestimate risks, and hence promoting speculative bubbles in the asset-price markets, whose bursting becomes even more debilitating than if financiers had been more cautious and less confident of a government bail-out. Economists refer to this as the “moral hazard” problem. Government intervention compounds the “moral hazard” problem.

Is Capitalism In Crisis?

Awhile back I wrote a piece called, “Capitalism and Why” and made it one of my pages here on my blog.  This is a follow-up to that piece.  With the US economy tumbling head long into ruin, the question is still revelent if not more so.  Massive financial failures, unemployment, outsourcing, so on and I am sure there are others that we should add, but we will start here.

Of course it is–it is ALWAYS in one form of crisis or another….it is the nature of the beast.

In an unregulated or deregulated system, creditors routinely manipulate people of low and moderate incomes, often desperate people, to take loans which they then sell to those higher on the financial food chain, creating a house of cards based on quick profits gained from such manipulation. No one is safe, including the investors in the institutions at the top of the financial food chain, those in the higher professional and managerial strata with income significantly higher than most of the people who think of themselves as “middle class.” This dynamic creates a political economy which, to paraphrase the 17th century Philosopher Thomas Hobbes, encourages a war of all against all.

Crises of this kind, that is, instability rooted in the anarchic drive of capital to find ever bigger markets, drive out competitors, commodify all goods, services, and social relations, is the heart of the capitalist system. Each crisis grows greater with capitalist consolidation and expansion.
This specific crisis is peculiar to the capitalist system as it has evolved into bank-controlled monopoly or finance capital. In recent decades this system, or state monopoly capitalism, has substantially done away with the regulatory reforms whose purpose was to save it from itself, devolving or deregulating itself into a speculative market jungle, but one where the state funds are still available to protect speculators.
Money is made not by creating new productive capacity in a national economy(which the old Robber Barons, with all their horrors, did do), but by financial piracy and loan sharking, manipulating stock prices, reducing dividends to general shareholders, merging companies, cutting jobs, cannibalizing pensions to repay the debts created such activities and walking away with super-profits.

Yes it is in crisis, but then it will always be in crisis.

Who Should Profit From The Bailout?

The quick answer is–not the pigs that put us in this trick bag of debt and crisis.

The situation is so dire that some type of dramatic action is needed to avoid disaster for U.S. workers. Organized labor, community groups and others are increasingly angry at the bailout currently on the table. Any plan before Congress must:

1) Protect homeowners faced with foreclosure by restructuring mortgage rates to be in line with family income.

2) Create economic stimulus for working people and small businesses.

3) Provide $100 billion in emergency relief to state and local governments wracked with budget cuts and diminished tax revenue.

4) Bar CEO severance packages and cap the pay of executives receiving a bailout.

5) Regulate banking and finance with transparent public oversight.

6) Maintain public control over monopolies like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac that have a decisive role in the economy.

7) Control speculation and increase revenues by taxing large financial transactions.

There is another drag on the economy that should be stopped–that is the War In Iraq which is costing in the neighborhood of multiple millions of dollars a day.

Developments are moving quickly and their full impact has yet to be felt, but let’s make sure that American workers — those who made this country rich — do not further suffer at the expense of the financial elites, those who have created this crisis.

I realize that I am not in the loop when it comes to the economic big-shots in Washington, but most of America is angry with this bailout.  Then I say find away that thew average person has a reason to support it.  Why?  Oh never fear, there will be a bailout, but the question should be who should profit?

Banks Dictate Conditions Of Bailout

As the Times article put it: “There were signs of the industry’s fingerprints on drafts of the legislation released over the weekend.

To put it bluntly, the American financial industry is preparing to deliver to the US Treasury every bad debt it accumulated over the years of reckless speculation and financial manipulation that generated super-profits and multimillion-dollar compensation packages for its top executives. And it is insuring that the American people pay super-inflated prices for their financial junk, so that they can launch a new and even bigger orgy of speculation.

The announcement of the bailout plan has set off a particularly ferocious competition for inclusion among the financial companies that are to be hired by the government to manage the operation. This plum job could, according to the Times, earn the winners $1 billion a year in fees.

All of these firms played major roles in creating the financial disaster from which they now seek to profit. They all are deeply involved in speculation on the assets that are to be bought by the government, and some, such as Morgan Stanley and JPMorgan Chase, have billions of such assets on their books.

Among the changes being called for by various industry lobby groups are:

* Pushing back the date of purchase of assets which the government will accept. The Treasury proposal released Saturday set the cut-off date at September 17 of this year. Some bankers are demanding that the date be changed to December of 2007, and, according to the Financial Times, some industry groups are lobbying for a clause that would “allow banks selling assets to the fund to account for any losses realized over a number of years.”

* Small banks are urging the government to buy loans they made to homebuilders and commercial developers.

* Some bankers are pushing for government support for municipal securities.

* The banking industry, according to the Wall Street Journal, “has gone directly to the SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission) demanding a letter changing US accounting rules that require banks to state the value of their assets at the market price.” They instead want their rotten assets to be valued at their price at the time of purchase—a change that would cost the government additional hundreds of billions in taxpayer money.

So I ask, is this bailout for the good of the nation or the good of speculators on Wall Street?

Speculators Under Every Rock

And now the rest of the story.

Institutional investors drove oil prices to all-time highs this summer, and the same players are also responsible for much of the $44-per-barrel loss since then, according to a Sept. 10 report that is being used to bolster calls for greater trading regulation.

The report from a hedge fund investor who has grown prominent in the oil speculation debate, Michael Masters, comes as crude oil has staged a 28% retreat in the past two months. But Masters and backers of his report—including many congressional Democrats—say prices could return to previous highs if reform legislation isn’t passed. “Americans won’t stand for being held up at the pump by these Wall Street scoundrels every time they fill up their gas tank,” Senator Maria Cantwell (D-Wash.) said on Sept. 10 at the report’s release. She was joined by Masters, Adam K. White of White Knight Research & Trading, Senator Byron Dorgan (D-N.D.), and Representative Bart Stupak (D-Mich.).

According to Masters’ report, an influx of “long-only” investors—large investors like pension funds and endowments that bet prices would rise—poured into the oil market in recent years. Their investments reached a peak on July 11, when oil prices hit an all-time high above $147 per barrel.

But many oil market experts and analysts disagree. While acknowledging that demand may be slowing, they argue that oil’s dramatic price decline is evidence that a speculative investment bubble is beginning to burst

Former CFTC regulator Michael Greenberger says that tougher policies and more oversight by the CFTC, initiated in May (BusinessWeek.com, 6/9/08), have caused investors to flee commodities markets. “The only constant variable in the oil market since the spring has been tougher CFTC measures and more oversight,” says Greenberger, a law professor at the University of Maryland and former head of the CFTC’s Trading & Markets Div. “If actual supply and demand were at work, [oil] prices would have spiked with Russia’s invasion of Georgia and the onset of hurricane season.”

Is It Speculation?

After the binge comes the purge. Merrill Lynch (MER) announced after the close of trading on July 28 that it had sold $11.1 billion in collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), or nearly 60% of its exposure to mortgage-related securities, to private equity firm Lone Star Capital Management for $6.7 billion as part of its latest effort to repair its tattered balance sheet.

At the same time, Merrill reduced its exposure to troubled XL Capital (XL) and other bond insurers, who provided insurance on Merrill’s CDOs. This “purging of assets,” as Oppenheimer (OPY) analyst Meredith Whitney described the sale in a July 29 research note, places the Wall Street stalwart closer to the end of its mortgage related troubles.

NOw, The Prez and McCain have flatly stated that speculation would not be rewarded.  Does that mean, if things turn south will the company that bought the troubled loans be part of the bailout?  The buyer is gambling that things will get better–that is speculation in my book.

Senate Approves Housing Bill

The US Senate has approved a rescue bill designed to prop up America’s battered housing market.

The new law creates a $300bn (£150bn) rescue fund to help thousands of homeowners get cheaper loans.

It may also be used to bail out the struggling mortgage giants Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, which own or guarantee around half the nation’s mortgage debt.

The bill has been approved in a very short time. President George Bush is expected to sign it into law next week.

Washington says the bill will help hundreds of thousands of Americans trapped by mortgages they can no longer afford.

They will be offered the chance to refinance with state-backed, fixed rate loans.

This is some relief for bewildered home owners, but in the same bill millions of taxpayer dollars will be used to bail out the corporations that lead the speculation in the housing markets.  I guess I would have to support the bill only because it will give the average home owner a chance to refinance at a lower rate.  Damned if I do and damned if I don’t.