Meeting Of The Psi Phi Society

First let me wish all the Fathers that follow and read IST a very Happy Father’s Day.  Enjoy your special day.

Yesterday I got to watch the start of 24 hrs du Le Mans……as a sports car racing fan this is a must…..I am pulling for the Ford GT and the Toyota in the “hybrid” category…..had to take a break from the race to attend my meeting…..

To celebrate the race I am preparing a Cassoulet served with a fine white Bordeaux and a baguette….very French…….oui?

The Psi Phi Society has nothing to do with science fiction or the channel on cable (SyFy)……it is just a friendly (mostly) discussion group that meets a couple times a year.

My Sunday begins and I would like to talk about the meeting of the Psi Phi Society…..we have our get together at a local steak house and hold our discussions and debates.

After our meal we settle in with a cocktail and decide what the topic will be for the evening…..the group is me and another professor, a preacher, a scientist (chemist), a nurse, a contractor and a local artist.

As you would imagine with a diverse group there would be diverse opinions on what the discuss….after about an hour of debate my fellow professor, a historian, brought up a topic that we all found interesting….what race were the Greeks and Romans?  (To be honest she picked up the check for all of us as a bribe to discuss her topic)

She brought up a paper that she had read recently on this subject…..to be on equal footing we asked the owner of the steakhouse (a friend) if he would print out the paper so that we could read it and then debate…..

Recent films about ancient Greece such as Troy, Helen of Troy, and 300, have used actors who are of Anglo-Saxon or Celtic ancestry (e.g. Brad Pitt, Gerard Butler). Recent films about ancient Rome, such as Gladiator and HBO’s series Rome, have done the same (e.g. Russell Crowe). Were the directors right, from an historical point of view? Were the ancient Greeks and Romans of North European stock?

Most classical historians today are silent on the subject. For example, Paul Cartledge, a professor of Greek culture at Cambridge, writes about his specialty, Sparta, for educated but non-academic readers, yet nowhere that I can find does he discuss the racial origins of the Spartans. Some years ago I asked several classics professors about the race of the ancient Greeks only to be met with shrugs that suggested that no one knew, and that it was not something worth looking into. Today, an interest in the race of the ancients seems to be taken as an unhealthy sign, and any evidence of their Nordic origins discounted for fear it might give rise to dangerous sentiments.

Source: What Race Were the Greeks and Romans? – The Unz Review

The discussion went into the late evening.

Me?

I came down on the side that the Greeks were of Minoan descent because they were great seafaring people and opened up new lands for colonies and settlements….thus Romans were descendants of these people as well…therefore olive skin with dark hair.

The evening ended when I got a call from a friend in Lebanon and had to cut my evening short.

We did decide to have another meeting next month…..

If you read the paper then….what do you think?

Settling in for a good a restful day and in prep for Monday and a new week……after all it is Father’s day….I hope everyone enjoys their special day……plus the race should be ending shortly…..Peace Out……chuq

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Meeting Of The Psi Phi Society

  1. That was a long read, (the link) but an interesting one. I have no personal theory about this, as I think it depends on both the exact place, and a given time period. For example, Alexander was from Macedonia, which was later part of Yugoslavia, and still considered to be part of the Balkans, in modern times. I suspect that most ‘early’ Greeks would have been European in appearance and colouring, but because of travel, trade, and invasion, racial mixing would have led to a wider diversity later on.
    Enjoy your motor racing!
    Best wishes, Pete.

  2. As far as I’m concerned, ANY discussion of ‘race’ is, from the outset, doomed to disappointment, and will never reach any viable conclusions. This is simply because it is all absurd, since there is only one race, the human race…

    My evidence is this: any human, of any color, or place of origin, or any other characteristic, CAN sexually cross with any other, exactly like any breed of dog, or cat, or cow. If they can do so, & the result is another human, then race, as we think of it, has, quite simply, no relevance, and no meaning other than what we individually assign to it…. If you can have sex with it, it’s another human; their color only matters to those who choose to make their own distinctions, according to their own prejudices. None of it has any basis in reality…..

    Sounds like a great group; too bad I’m 2200 miles away, or I’d request a membership.Stay cool, bro, & have a good time with the family….

    gigoid, the dubious

    😎

  3. For a long time it was supposed (and taught academically) that Mankind derived from some remote obscure place in some part of Africa but more recent discoveries of human remains have suggested a possibility that original Man might have originated from somewhere in The Mid East. Either way I believe the ancient Romans and Greeks were either of Mid Eastern origin or Indo-European origin, were originally darker skinned and evolved into their olive complexion by centuries of exposure to the Mediterannean climate. Their inventiveness and overall cultural achievements — architecture, philosophy, record-keeping etc., suggest some possible connection to an Arabian-type culture (Arabs gave us math) and would argue against African origins whose cultures have left far less academia .. except for the one outstanding example posed by the Ancient Egyptian Culture … a culture which was heavily influenced by Rome at the time of General Anthony’s dealings with Queen Cleopatra.

      1. It did support the first civilizations but they stared elsewhere….besides the Greeks and Romans were more Minoan like than the rest.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s