Professor’s Classroom
Subject: Am Government/Federalism
In the beginning there was the debate on the formation of the US Constitution….it raged in 1787 and continued for a couple years, the back and forth between the Federalist and the anti-Federalists…..finally, they settled on the checks and balances that we so cherish now of the three branches, executive, judicial and legislative…….and for awhile it work nicely…..but that was to give way, the cooperation of the branches, into the dysfunctional family we have now…..
Partisanship has for a generation brought the functioning of the Congress to a standstill, especially the Senate, the original idea was that the Congress would listen, debate, the act on any given proposal…..that 3 part system is no longer working…there is little listening, there is absolutely NO debate and action is slowed to a pace that makes most knowledgeable people ill. Madison warned of the result of partisanship in Federalist #10 and he also said that there were two ways of controlling factionalism, they being, to remove its causes and to control its effects.
“a number of citizens, whether amounting to a minority or majority of the whole, who are united and actuated by some common impulse of passion, or of interest, adverse to the rights of other citizens, or to the permanent and aggregate interests of the community.”
In today’s Congress we have extreme factionalism or partisanship, at least on the part of the GOP….the Party of NO is an accurate description……they refuse to listen….they refuse to debate…..what they call debate is nothing but misinformation that is not geared to finding answers to the problems confronting the country but rather to defeat ALL issues not theirs….this factionalism has brought the once mighty Congress to a stand still…..making many Americans doubt the validity of their claim to speak for them……
For the reason I say the Legislative branch is dysfunctional….NOTHING moves through the system as desired by the Founders, instead there are sound bites and hyperbole…little constructive……and now the American people are seeing just how much of a game Congress is…..it is controlled by forces outside the people, the ones that elected them have NO voice in what is to be done….instead it is the cash that is influencing legislation, not the needs of Americans….
With a broken legislative branch, the other two work not at all, so the cherished Federal system is NOT working properly…..Garry Wills argued against Madison and Federalist #10:
“Minorities can make use of dispersed and staggered governmental machinery to clog, delay, slow down, hamper, and obstruct the majority. But these weapons for delay are given to the minority irrespective of its factious or nonfactious character; and they can be used against the majority irrespective of its factious or nonfactious character. What Madison prevents is not faction, but action. What he protects is not the common good but delay as such.”
Read the above quote again……(time for the re-read)…….now look back at the past year of 2009 and the antics in the Senate and to a lesser extent, the House……..does it sound familiar now? While one may like what Madison had to say, I think that the quote by Wills is far more accurate in the shedding of light on the modern legislative branch.
The Congress is NOT working in the electorates best interest……..these people are self-serving and sanctimonious ….they personally profit from special interests and in doing so they are NOT to be trusted…..also in doing so they are only pretending to do the people’s work…the extremely sad part in this game is that the people actually realize they are being duped and allow it to continue……so with that said you tell me who is more PATHETIC……the liars or the ones that allow the lie?