Once again I am about to let fly my now famous historical perspectives….
I think we all can agree that the Middle East as it is today is a mess…….as I student of conflicts I am always looking for a possible way to end all these hostilities and bring some sort of peacefulness to the region.
What sort of peace could there possibly be and then I thought about the Westphalian Peace Treaty……it ended the 30 years war……
The Thirty Years’ War (1618-48) began when Holy Roman Emperor Ferdinand II of Bohemia attempted to curtail the religious activities of his subjects, sparking rebellion among Protestants. The war came to involve the major powers of Europe, with Sweden, France, Spain and Austria all waging campaigns primarily on German soil. Known in part for the atrocities committed by mercenary soldiers, the war ended with a series of treaties that made up the Peace of Westphalia. The fallout reshaped the religious and political map of central Europe, setting the stage for the old centralized Roman Catholic empire to give way to a community of sovereign states.
Why the Peace of Westphalia, which helped end a series of bloody wars in seventeenth century Europe, could work for the Middle East today.
Between 1618 and 1648, central Europe, and the Holy Roman Empire in particular, was devastated by a series of conflicts that were caused by competing visions of political order, great power, and dynastic rivalries, and that were exacerbated by religious differences. This soon came to be called the Thirty Years’ War. But the Peace of Westphalia, which successfully ended the German phase of the conflict, has been much misunderstood.
The 1648 settlement is widely thought to have inaugurated a modern system of sovereign independent nation-states in Europe (often referred to as the Westphalian system). And, as the argument goes, when that concept was later applied to the Middle East after the fall of the Ottoman Empire, it actually contributed to much of the region’s current dysfunction. But in reality, the Westphalia settlement did something quite different from what has been commonly thought. It set up a system of limited sovereignty for the numerous states of the Holy Roman Empire (formally known as imperial estates, which were the component territories of the empire, ruled by princes or city councils). It also created legal mechanisms for settling disputes and offered mutual guarantees for upholding the treaty’s terms, which taken altogether, formed a system of collective security.
Source: A Westphalian Peace for the Middle East | Foreign Affairs
Apparently what the world is doing these days will never lead to a peaceful conclusion of the violence and destruction.
Why not take some time and use a previous agreement as a template that could lead to an end to this deadly games?
The Middle East has been a mess throughout all my conscious memory and I am sure that thanks to the UN, The meddling of The United States, The never-ending tribal warfare and religious warfare, it will be a mess for the forseeable future and likely beyond even that time frame.
That is what they said about the Balkans and Lebanon….they are not perfect but they are calmer than in the past…
Their calm will come and go with the emotional tides of those who reside in the region and those who wish to exploit the region.
We are one of the worse exploiters….so I agree a bit with your conclusion…
Thank you.
Ah, my friend, your optimism, while admirable, is probably misplaced. I believe your last two lines summed up the reality of life on this planet pretty accurately, to wit:
“Apparently what the world is doing these days will never lead to a peaceful conclusion of the violence and destruction.
Why not take some time and use a previous agreement as a template that could lead to an end to this deadly games?”
As to the first, no, it will never lead to any peaceful conclusions.
This is because of the answer to the second line, which is: Those who live for profit and the power it brings them over others see no advantage to bringing it to an end, so, it won’t happen, until the general run of people no longer buys into their bullshit… and, that, unfortunately, never has, and never will happen, for people are too invested in their own fantasies of specialness, for being born wherever they were born, or believing in one of the many choices for biggest imaginary friend…
As long as religion and nationalism exist, people, by their nature, will make war, for they will kill at the drop of a cliche to protect the delusions held by their fragile egos, which do not like to admit being wrong, or to look too closely at what is real….
gigoid, the dubious
Yes. And for goodness’ sake, stop shipping them more weapons. That should at least be obvious.
speaking of the Peace of Westphalia, I ran into this just the other week:
Thanx for the link…chuq
Very funny…..historical humor is great….thanx chuq