A “Great Replacement Theory”

It is time to call a spade a spade.

There has been lots of typing trying to explain what is happening in this country politically….some of it is detailed and in-depth but there is a simpler explanation.

Donald Trump made clear on the Philadelphia debate stage this week, as he has throughout his three presidential campaigns, the basis of his run for office. Trump is running on the platform that non-white immigration is an existential threat to the nation. This time around, Trump has made his primary message, the so-called Great Replacement Theory(GRT), more vivid than ever. It is therefore of existential importance in understanding the stakes of this election to have clearly in mind what has happened in the past when GRT has been the central driving narrative both of individuals and of states.

According to the Great Replacement Theory, the nation’s greatness, its traditions and its practitioners, are existentially imperiled by an influx of foreign races, ethnicities or religions. The foreign elements are sometimes described in the narrative of GRT, as vermin or diseases. 

GRT was central to the official Nazi motivation for the genocide of the Jews of Europe. Hitler blamed the loss of World War I on Jewish betrayal of Germany. But this betrayal, for Hitler, was intimately connected to the Great Replacement Theory, via the introduction of Black soldiers in the French army subsequently occupying the Rhineland, the so-called “Black Horror on the Rhine.” In Mein Kampf, Hitler writes:

It was and is the Jews who bring the Negroes into the Rhineland, always with the same secret thought and clear aim of ruining the hated white race by the necessarily resulting bastardization, throwing it down from its cultural and political height, and himself rising to be its master.

With the benefit of hindsight, the idea that Jews betrayed Germany in World War I in order to use the occupying French army to bring Black Senegalese soldiers in to ruin the white race by rape and race mixing seems utterly unhinged. It is hard to fathom that this crazed conspiracy theory justified for many Germans the mass murder of two out of every three of Europe’s Jews. But our descendants will also find it hard to understand why so many Americans find Trump’s claims that non-white immigrants to the United States are savages who eat pets, criminally insane murderers and drugs dealers who nevertheless somehow manage to get it together to vote fraudulently en masse in election to be plausible. In both cases, the bizarre nature of these claims stands in stark contrast to their obvious political power.

https://www.salon.com/2024/09/13/donald-is-openly-running-a-great-replacement-theory-campaign/

All this is nothing new…..I recall when the boat people were arriving in the 70s a story locally was that pets were being eaten by them and that Vietnam had sent us criminals….any of that sound familiar?

I Read, I Write, You Know

“lego ergo scribo”

6 thoughts on “A “Great Replacement Theory”

  1. Trump is just replaying Hitler in the 1930s, and he’s not alone. The Italian and Hungarian leaders are trotting out the same racist scare-tactics.

    Best wishes, Pete.

  2. I do not agree with Trump on the idea that non-white immigration is an existential threat to the nation, but I do agree that non-white immigration (Or any immigration at all regardless of color) that is ILLEGAL is an existential threat to the nation. I also believe that the Koran calls for the replacement of infidels with believers so from that standpoint, Islamic immigration would be added to the existential threat in my opinion. And yes the referenced individual is most likely playing with the Hitler playbook but underneath the hate, there is some area for legitimate concern as the rampage of uncontrolled undocumented immigration is threatening the resources that sustain the host country (education, medical, social services, etc.) which, in this instance is The United States …There are others but we seem to have the greatest influx of the immigrants at this point in time.

    A tyrant (Who has the permission of the highest court in the land) who wants to eliminate all opposition and all his or her political enemies) will eventually probably seek a way to obtain the public voting rolls and work to decimate the lives of all who cast a vote against him or her through manipulation of the loyalists in courts and local jurisdictions…which mechanism has been in place and working for quite some time now.

Leave a Reply